Substitutions — Question 4

PDF ↗

Question 4

Consider the nonseparable-looking equation y′=(x+y)2−1,y(0)=1.y'=(x+y)^2-1,\qquad y(0)=1.

Tasks

  1. Set u=x+yu=x+y. Derive its differential equation, including the derivative of xx.

  2. Solve the transformed IVP, recover yy, and find its maximal interval containing 00.

  3. Determine the minimum of the selected solution and verify the original equation.

  4. Find the original solution represented by the constant transformed value u=0u=0. Explain why dividing by u2u^2 would miss it and why it is not a constant function yy.

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 2-5-004
Show solutionHide solution

Question 4 – Solution

Strategy. Replace the repeated linear combination by one variable. The extra derivative of xx cancels the constant term in the equation.

Step 1: Reduce to a separable IVP. For u=x+yu=x+y, u′=1+y′=u2u'=1+y'=u^2, and u(0)=1u(0)=1. Separating on the nonzero branch gives −1u=x+C,C=−1,u=11−x.-\frac 1u=x+C,\qquad C=-1,\qquad u=\frac 1{1-x}. Thus y=−x+11−x,I=(−∞,1).\boxed{y=-x+\frac 1{1-x},\qquad I=(-\infty,1)}. The only finite obstruction is the pole at x=1x=1, where y→+∞y\to+\infty from the left.

Step 2: Find the minimum and verify. Differentiation gives y′=−1+(1−x)−2y'=-1+(1-x)^{-2}. On II this is negative for x<0x<0, zero at 00, and positive for 0<x<10<x<1. Hence the unique global minimum on II is y(0)=1\boxed{y(0)=1}.

Also x+y=1/(1−x)x+y=1/(1-x), so (x+y)2−1=(1−x)−2−1=y′(x+y)^2-1=(1-x)^{-2}-1=y', and the initial value checks directly.

Step 3: Restore the constant transformed branch. The equation u′=u2u'=u^2 also has u≡0u\equiv 0. In the original variables it gives y=−x\boxed{y=-x} on all of ℝ\mathbb R. Its derivative is −1-1 and its right-hand side is 02−1=−10^2-1=-1, so it is valid. Division by u2u^2 excludes it. A constant value of a combination of xx and yy need not represent a constant value of yy.

See the diagram in the original worksheet below.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 2-5-004

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.