Question 3
A student tries to solve and writes Tasks
Identify the precise error by expanding the student’s claimed product derivative.
Find a correct integrating factor and solve the IVP.
Verify the solution by direct substitution in .
Replace the initial condition by , with any real number. Find the resulting family and prove directly that two different choices of cannot produce intersecting solution curves.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 3 – Solution
Strategy. The integrating factor must match the signed coefficient of . Check its product derivative before integrating.
Step 1: Diagnose the sign error. The student’s derivative is whereas multiplying the original equation by gives . These expressions differ in the sign of the term. The required coefficient is , so .
Step 2: Correct integration. Multiplication gives Since , , and
Step 3: Verify. Differentiating explicitly, The initial value is also zero.
Step 4: Vary the initial datum. The general initial value sets , giving For distinct , at every real . Hence their graphs never intersect. The nonintersection follows from the explicit homogeneous difference, not merely from a sketch.