Assessing Relative Importance of Resonance Structures — Question 9

Section 2-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 487–488

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Counting drawings alone cannot rank stabilization

The summary gives only contributor counts and qualitative features, not energies or complete molecular identities.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the flaw in the shortcut.

  2. Which additional information would matter?

  3. Can the supplied summary establish a quantitative stabilization ranking?

Question 9 - Solution

Counting drawings alone cannot rank stabilization

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

Contributors do not carry equal weight simply because they can be drawn. Several very unfavorable drawings may contribute little.

(b)

Their validity, relative energies, octets, charge placement, orbital overlap and a consistent reference for stabilization all matter. Molecular identity is also essential.

(c)

No. The summary is insufficient. Counting drawings is not an energy calculation, especially across different systems.