Assessing Relative Importance of Resonance Structures — Question 10

Section 2-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 489–490

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Validate before ranking an acylium pair

O has two pairs in A and one in B and C. C is proposed with a lone pair on its triple-bonded carbon.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
C: proposed
  1. Which proposed drawing must be rejected before ranking?

  2. Compare the carbon octets in A and B.

  3. Choose the more important valid contributor and state the decisive criterion.

Question 10 - Solution

Validate before ranking an acylium pair

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

(a)

C must be rejected: its central carbon has four bond orders plus a pair, giving ten surrounding electrons. Its stated carbon charge also conflicts with that inventory.

(b)

A has a six-electron carbon. B gives carbon four bond orders and an octet; O also has an octet.

(c)

B is more important because it gives every second-row atom a complete octet, despite placing the positive formal charge on O.