Assessing Relative Importance of Resonance Structures — Question 8

Section 2-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 485–486

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Compare two electron-deficient carbon sites with a stated rule

For this qualitative comparison, use the rule that an otherwise comparable secondary carbocation site is better stabilized by alkyl substitution than a primary site.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

  1. Classify the positive carbon in each contributor.

  2. Which contributor is favored by the supplied rule?

  3. Why does this rule not imply an exact percentage contribution?

Question 8 - Solution

Compare two electron-deficient carbon sites with a stated rule

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.↔\longleftrightarrowMolecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.

(a)

The left drawing places + on a carbon with two carbon neighbors: secondary. The right places + on a terminal carbon with one carbon neighbor: primary.

(b)

The left contributor is favored by the stated substitution criterion. Both contain one six-electron carbon and have the same total charge.

(c)

The rule supplies a qualitative preference, not a numerical energy gap or a uniquely defined weighting scheme. No exact percentage follows.