Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions — Question 9

PDF ↗

Question 9

An inverse design seeks a continuous potential qq on [0,1][0,1] for −y″+q(x)y=λy,y(0)=y(1)=0.-y''+q(x)y=\lambda y,\qquad y(0)=y(1)=0. For the constructive part, prescribe λ=π2\lambda=\pi^2 and y=sin⁡πx+14sin⁡2πxy=\sin\pi x+\tfrac 14\sin 2\pi x. Eigenfunctions are required to be C2C^2.

Tasks

  1. Show that the alternative target y=x(1−x)y=x(1-x) cannot be an eigenfunction for any continuous qq and any finite real λ\lambda. Explain the endpoint obstruction.

  2. For the trigonometric target, recover qq explicitly and extend it continuously to both endpoints. Compute q(0)q(0) and q(1)q(1) and verify the differential equation.

  3. Prove that the target is positive on (0,1)(0,1) and has simple endpoint zeros. For any C2C^2 test function vv with zero endpoints, put z=v/yz=v/y inside the interval and derive ∫01[v′2+(q−λ)v2]dx=∫01y2z′2dx\int_0^1[v'^2+(q-\lambda)v^2]dx=\int_0^1y^2z'^2dx.

  4. Use this identity to prove that no real eigenvalue can lie below π2\pi^2, and that every eigenfunction with eigenvalue π2\pi^2 is a multiple of the designed target. Address the boundary term in the identity.

Original worksheet page 1: question and worked solution for 8-2-009
Show solutionHide solution

Question 9 – Solution

Strategy. Recover the potential where the target is nonzero, then use endpoint regularity and a factored energy identity to certify the design.

Step 1: Reject an incompatible target. For y=x(1−x)y=x(1-x), division inside the interval would require q=λ+y″/y=λ−2/[x(1−x)]q=\lambda+y''/y=\lambda-2/[x(1-x)], which is unbounded at both ends. Equivalently, continuity of the equation at zero would require −y″(0)+q(0)y(0)=2=λy(0)=0-y''(0)+q(0)y(0)=2=\lambda y(0)=0. No continuous potential can work.

Step 2: Construct a regular potential. Write c=cos⁡πxc=\cos\pi x. The target is y=sin⁡πx(1+c/2)y=\sin\pi x(1+c/2) and y″=−π2sin⁡πx(1+2c)y''=-\pi^2\sin\pi x(1+2c). Consequently q(x)=−3π2c2+c,q(0)=−π2,q(1)=3π2.\boxed{q(x)=-\frac{3\pi^2c}{2+c},\qquad q(0)=-\pi^2,\quad q(1)=3\pi^2.} Since 2+c≥12+c\geq 1, the formula is continuous on the closed interval. Substitution gives qy=(λy+y″)qy=(\lambda y+y''), verifying the equation inside; continuity verifies it at the endpoints as well.

Step 3: Factor the energy. The factor 1+c/21+c/2 lies between 1/21/2 and 3/23/2, so y>0y>0 inside. The endpoint derivatives are y′(0)=3π/2y'(0)=3\pi/2 and y′(1)=−π/2y'(1)=-\pi/2, both nonzero. With v=yzv=yz and y″=(q−λ)yy''=(q-\lambda)y, expansion gives v′2+(q−λ)v2=y2z′2+(yy′z2)′.v'^2+(q-\lambda)v^2=y^2z'^2+(yy'z^2)'. For zero-endpoint C2C^2 functions vv, the simple zeros of yy imply that z=v/yz=v/y and z′z' stay bounded near either endpoint, by Taylor expansion. Thus [yy′z2]01=0[yy'z^2]_0^1=0 and integration proves the requested identity.

Step 4: Certify the lowest eigenvalue and its eigenspace. If vv is a nonzero eigenfunction with eigenvalue ν\nu, integration by parts and the identity yield (ν−π2)∫01v2dx=∫01y2z′2dx≥0.(\nu-\pi^2)\int_0^1v^2dx=\int_0^1y^2z'^2dx\geq 0. Thus ν≥π2\nu\geq\pi^2, and the constructed nonzero yy attains this bound. Equality forces z′=0z'=0 inside, hence v=Cyv=Cy. Therefore π2\pi^2 is the lowest real eigenvalue and its eigenspace is precisely span⁡{y}\operatorname{span}\{y\}.

Original worksheet page 2: question and worked solution for 8-2-009

Original worksheet layout. Use Enlarge or open the PDF for a closer view.