Question 5
Problem
A simple, piecewise smooth closed curve is traversed once clockwise. Explain why may be positive even though area cannot be negative.
See the diagram in the original worksheet below.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 5 – Solution
See the diagram in the original worksheet below.
Solution
A line integral around a closed curve is signed: reversing the direction of traversal reverses the sign because changes sign.
For a positively oriented, counterclockwise curve , Green’s theorem gives Thus for counterclockwise traversal.
If the same boundary is traversed clockwise, the line integral changes sign: Therefore, can be positive for clockwise motion; the sign describes orientation, not a negative or positive physical area by itself.
A direction-independent formula for geometric area is Equivalently, use with counterclockwise orientation or reverse the bounds when necessary.