Resonance — Question 7

Section 8-12 · Chemistry pages 1519–1520

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Move two electron pairs to preserve a carbon octet

A carboxylate contributor is R–C(=Oa_a)–Ob−_b^-, with two lone pairs on Oa_a and three on Ob_b. R is a fixed substituent connected by one single bond.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Describe the two simultaneous electron-pair reallocations that produce the equivalent alternative contributor.

  2. Why would adding the second C=O bond without removing the first be invalid for this carbon?

Question 7 - Solution

Move two electron pairs to preserve a carbon octet

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Move one Ob_b lone pair into the C–Ob_b link to make a double bond, and move the original C=Oa_a pi pair onto Oa_a to make a lone pair. The negative formal charge changes from Ob_b to Oa_a.

(b) Analysis

Carbon already has four bond-order units: one to R, two to Oa_a and one to Ob_b. Adding another without compensating would give five, or ten electrons around second-period C. The paired shifts preserve its octet and the total electron count.

Check and interpretation

No nucleus or proton moves during this resonance reassignment.