Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Interpret a fractional formal-charge average
Carbonate has three equivalent contributors. Each gives C formal charge 0, one O charge 0 and the other two O atoms charge -1. Consider equal weights.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the formal-charge average on each oxygen and verify the total.
Does the average mean each carbonate ion contains one-third of three separately charged oxygen species?
Question 8 - Solution
Interpret a fractional formal-charge average
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For a chosen O the average is . Three such averages sum to -2, while C contributes zero.
(b) Analysis
No. The fractions summarize equivalent contributors of one delocalized ion. They are not a mixture composition or literal fractional isolated-ion identities. A physical partial-charge analysis can also give values different from these formal averages.
Check and interpretation
The conserved net charge remains an integer even when descriptive averages are fractional.