Resonance — Question 6

Section 8-12 · Chemistry pages 1517–1518

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Use unequal weights only when they are supplied

Two hypothetical amide contributors are assigned weights 0.75 and 0.25 for this exercise. A has C=O, C–N, O charge 0 and N charge 0. B has C–O, C=N, O charge -1 and N charge +1.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compute the model average C–O and C–N bond orders.

  2. Compute the model average O and N formal-charge contributions and explain their limitation.

Question 6 - Solution

Use unequal weights only when they are supplied

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

C–O averages 0.75(2)+0.25(1)=1.750.75(2)+0.25(1)=1.75; C–N averages 0.75(1)+0.25(2)=1.250.75(1)+0.25(2)=1.25.

(b) Analysis

O averages -0.25 and N +0.25 in this formal bookkeeping. The weights are supplied model inputs, not measured populations, and these averages are not automatically unique physical partial charges from electron density.

Check and interpretation

Unlike equivalent contributors, inequivalent contributors must not automatically be assigned equal importance.