Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Reject a contributor that preserves count but violates a shell
NO has eighteen valence electrons. Proposal A has one N=O, one N–O, one N lone pair, two lone pairs on the double-bonded O and three on the other O. Proposal B has O=N=O, one N lone pair and two lone pairs on each O.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Count the total and the electrons around N in each proposal.
Which is allowed by the ordinary second-period octet rule, and why is total count alone insufficient?
Question 5 - Solution
Reject a contributor that preserves count but violates a shell
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A has six bonding plus twelve nonbonding electrons, total eighteen; N has six bonding plus two nonbonding, giving eight. B has eight bonding plus ten nonbonding, also eighteen; N has eight bonding plus two nonbonding, giving ten.
(b) Analysis
A is valid; B violates the ordinary N octet. A correct molecular total does not guarantee a valid local shell allocation. The other valid major contributor swaps the single and double O roles in A.
Check and interpretation
Every proposed contributor must pass both global and atom-by-atom checks.