Early Experiments to Characterize the Atom — Question 9

Section 2-4 · Chemistry pages 263–264

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Normalize scattering counts before comparing targets

At one angle, run I records 20 scattered events from 1.00×1061.00\times10^6 incident particles; run II records 60 from 3.00×1063.00\times10^6. Detection conditions are otherwise identical. For a separate thin-target comparison, assume scattering probability is proportional to foil thickness.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare the scattering fractions for the two runs.

  2. Does the threefold raw count establish a stronger scattering probability?

  3. If foil thickness alone doubles in the thin-target regime, predict the expected event count for 1.00×1061.00\times10^6 incident particles using run I as reference. State why very thick foils may violate the simple assumption.

Question 9 - Solution

Normalize scattering counts before comparing targets

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both fractions equal 2.00×10−52.00\times10^{-5}. The second run has three times the exposure and three times the detected count.

(b) Analysis

No. The probability per incident particle is unchanged. Raw counts must be normalized by incident number and, where relevant, detector efficiency and geometry.

(c) Conclusion

Doubling thickness predicts about 40 events for the same incident number. Thick foils can permit multiple scattering and substantial energy loss, so a simple proportional single-scattering model may no longer apply.

Check and interpretation

The predicted count is an expectation, not a guarantee for one finite trial.