Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Match an experimental result to the conclusion it supports
Consider three evidence sets: P, negatively charged cathode-ray carriers with similar charge-to-mass ratios across source materials; Q, drop charges occurring in common increments; R, rare large-angle alpha scattering from a thin foil. A student says R alone proves that nuclei contain neutrons.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Match P, Q and R to common negative constituents, a charge unit, and a concentrated atomic center.
Explain why the neutron claim does not follow from R alone.
Explain how combining independent evidence improves an atomic model without making every inferred detail equally certain.
Question 10 - Solution
Match an experimental result to the conclusion it supports
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
P supports a common negative constituent, the electron. Q supports a shared charge increment. R supports a concentrated scattering center under the tested interaction model.
(b) Analysis
Large-angle scattering constrains the distribution of charge and mass, not the detailed neutral constituents inside the center. Evidence specifically distinguishing neutral massive particles is needed to establish neutrons.
(c) Conclusion
Different experiments constrain different model features. Consistency across charge, mass and scattering results narrows possibilities, but one should preserve the distinction between directly measured quantities and additional structural inferences.
Check and interpretation
A nuclear model need not already contain every detail of the modern nucleus to explain scattering.