Early Experiments to Characterize the Atom — Question 8

Section 2-4 · Chemistry pages 261–262

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Separate radiation types by electric deflection

Three narrow beams travel rightward between a positive upper plate and a negative lower plate. Beam A contains alpha particles with charge +2e+2e; beam B contains beta-minus particles with charge −e-e; beam C contains uncharged gamma photons. Consider electric deflection only.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict whether each beam bends upward, downward or remains undeflected.

  2. Can charge signs alone determine which charged beam bends more?

  3. Why does an undeflected beam not by itself prove that no material or energy is traveling through the apparatus?

Question 8 - Solution

Separate radiation types by electric deflection

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The field points downward. A bends downward, B upward and C remains electrically undeflected because the photons have no charge.

(b) Analysis

No. The amount of deflection also depends on mass, speed or momentum, field strength and path length. A larger charge magnitude alone is insufficient to rank the paths.

(c) Conclusion

Neutral radiation can carry energy and momentum without an electric force. Lack of deflection demonstrates a limited response to this test, not absence of a beam.

Check and interpretation

Beta-minus is specified; a positron beam would have the opposite charge sign.