Two- and Three-Dimensional Electron Traps — Question 8

Section 39-6 · Physics pages 6526–6527

Question 8 Field polarization selects which confinement index can change in a dipole transition The three-dimensional box eigenfunctions factor into normalized one-dimensional functions unx(x)uny(y)unz(z). A weak x-polarized field couples through x. In one dimension the off-diagonal position matrix element is nonzero only for opposite-parity indices. Lx Lz Ly Ex Schematic; labels, not drawing lengths, specify the data. (a) Factor the dipole matrix element and state the index selection rules. (b) From state (1,1,1), compare transitions to (2,1,1) and (2,2,1), including whether another linear polarization can permit the latter in first-order dipole coupling.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 8 - Solution Field polarization selects which confinement index can change in a dipole transition Lx Lz Ly Ex (a) Method and calculation ⟨rxryrz|x|nxnynz⟩= xrxnxδrynyδrznz. ry = ny, rz = nz, rx + nx odd for an off-diagonal transition. (b) Interpretation and further calculation (1, 1, 1) →(2, 1, 1) allowed for x polarization . ⟨221|(exx + eyy + ezz)|111⟩= 0 ⇒111 →221 dipole-forbidden . Physical check Each linear coordinate operator can change only its own factor. Energy matching alone does not guarantee a dipole transition.

Question 8

Field polarization selects which confinement index can change in a dipole transition

The three-dimensional box eigenfunctions factor into normalized one-dimensional functions unx(x)uny(y)unz(z)u_{n_x}(x)u_{n_y}(y)u_{n_z}(z). A weak x-polarized field couples through x. In one dimension the off-diagonal position matrix element is nonzero only for opposite-parity indices.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Factor the dipole matrix element and state the index selection rules.

  2. From state (1,1,1), compare transitions to (2,1,1) and (2,2,1), including whether another linear polarization can permit the latter in first-order dipole coupling.

Question 8 - Solution

Field polarization selects which confinement index can change in a dipole transition

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Method and calculation

⟨rxryrz|x|nxnynz⟩=xrxnxδrynyδrznz.\langle r_xr_yr_z|x|n_xn_yn_z\rangle=x_{r_xn_x}\delta_{r_yn_y}\delta_{r_zn_z}.ry=ny,rz=nz,rx+nx oddfor an off-diagonal transition.\boxed{r_y=n_y,\quad r_z=n_z,\quad r_x+n_x\text{ odd}}\quad\text{for an off-diagonal transition}.

(b) Interpretation and further calculation

(1,1,1)→(2,1,1) allowed for x polarization.\boxed{(1,1,1)\to(2,1,1)\text{ allowed for x polarization}}.⟨221|(exx+eyy+ezz)|111⟩=0⇒111→221 dipole-forbidden.\langle221|(e_xx+e_yy+e_zz)|111\rangle=0\Rightarrow\boxed{111\to221\text{ dipole-forbidden}}.

Physical check

Each linear coordinate operator can change only its own factor. Energy matching alone does not guarantee a dipole transition.