Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Recognize resonance stabilization at an allylic cation
These are resonance contributors of one allylic carbocation, not two equilibrating constitutional isomers.
| One contributor |
| Another contributor |
What electron pair moves between contributors?
Do any nuclei migrate?
Why can an allylic halide depart more readily than a comparable simple primary halide?
Question 4 - Solution
Recognize resonance stabilization at an allylic cation
| One contributor |
| Another contributor |
(a)
The pi pair shifts toward the adjacent positively charged carbon, relocating the formal positive charge to the other terminal carbon.
(b)
No. The atomic connectivity and positions are unchanged; only the electron assignment differs.
(c)
The positive charge can be delocalized over the allylic framework. A primary label alone therefore does not describe the full stability of the ionization product.