Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Compare cations while holding the leaving group fixed
Compare simple ionization tendencies in a suitable polar ionizing medium; disregard special neighboring-group effects.
| A |
| B |
Which would form a primary cation?
Which would form a tertiary cation?
Why does this favor the SN1 tendency of one substrate?
Question 3 - Solution
Compare cations while holding the leaving group fixed
| A |
| B |
(a)
A would form an ethyl cation, a simple primary cation.
(b)
B would form the tertiary tert-butyl cation.
(c)
Alkyl substitution stabilizes the developing positive charge, so B has much greater ordinary SN1 propensity. This is a relative mechanistic tendency, not a numerical rate prediction.