The SN1 Mechanism — Question 3

Section 7-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1495–1496

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Compare cations while holding the leaving group fixed

Compare simple ionization tendencies in a suitable polar ionizing medium; disregard special neighboring-group effects.

A
B
  1. Which would form a primary cation?

  2. Which would form a tertiary cation?

  3. Why does this favor the SN1 tendency of one substrate?

Question 3 - Solution

Compare cations while holding the leaving group fixed

A
B

(a)

A would form an ethyl cation, a simple primary cation.

(b)

B would form the tertiary tert-butyl cation.

(c)

Alkyl substitution stabilizes the developing positive charge, so B has much greater ordinary SN1 propensity. This is a relative mechanistic tendency, not a numerical rate prediction.