Reactions of Carboxylic Acids — Question 7

Section 21-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 4883–4884

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Identify why hydroxide is a poor leaving group from an acid

Consider a proposed direct acyl substitution that expels OH-minus from the neutral acid without activation.

  1. What makes this leaving step unfavorable?

  2. How can proton transfer change the departing group in an acid-catalyzed pathway?

  3. Does the acid catalyst change the carbon skeleton?

Question 7 - Solution

Identify why hydroxide is a poor leaving group from an acid

(a)

Hydroxide is a strongly basic, poor leaving group.

(b)

Protonation can allow departure as neutral water after the required addition/proton-transfer steps.

(c)

No. The catalyst facilitates bond changes and is regenerated; it does not supply a new carbon atom.