Reactions of Carboxylic Acids — Question 6

Section 21-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 4881–4882

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Distinguish an ammonium salt from an amide

Mix propanoic acid with methylamine at room temperature without a coupling reagent or dehydrating conditions.

  1. What immediate transformation is favored?

  2. What ions describe the salt?

  3. Why is an amide not justified merely by writing acid plus amine?

Question 6 - Solution

Distinguish an ammonium salt from an amide

CH3CH2CO2H + CH3NH2 <=> CH3CH2CO2- + CH3NH3+\text{CH3CH2CO2H + CH3NH2 <=> CH3CH2CO2- + CH3NH3+}

(a)

Acid-base proton transfer is favored.

(b)

The ions are propanoate and methylammonium.

(c)

Amide formation requires suitable activation or dehydration; simple proton transfer does not create the new covalent acyl C–N bond.