Dipole Moments and Molecular Polarity — Question 4

Section 1-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 217–218

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Tetrahedral cancellation and partial substitution

Assume ideal tetrahedral directions, equal C–F bond-dipole magnitude bb, and neglect C–H dipoles for B. For any two tetrahedral unit vectors, 𝒖i⋅𝒖j=−1/3\mathbf u_i\cdot\mathbf u_j=-1/3.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B
  1. Explain cancellation in A.

  2. Derive the resultant magnitude for B.

  3. State the limitation introduced by neglecting C–H polarity.

Question 4 - Solution

Tetrahedral cancellation and partial substitution

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
A
Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
B

The drawing uses wedges for depth; paper angles are not tetrahedral interbond angles.

(a)

The four equivalent tetrahedral vectors sum to zero, so ideal has no molecular dipole.

(b)

B retains two C–F vectors. Their sum has squared magnitude b2|𝒖1+𝒖2|2=b2(2+2[−1/3])=43b2.b^2|\mathbf u_1+\mathbf u_2|^2=b^2(2+2[-1/3])=\tfrac43b^2. Thus μ=2b/3≈1.155b\mu=2b/\sqrt3\approx1.155b, nonzero.

(c)

Real includes the complete charge distribution, C–H contributions and possible geometric deviations. The calculation demonstrates incomplete cancellation in the stipulated model; it is not an exact experimental dipole prediction.