Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Cancellation in a trigonal plane
Assign equal outward bond-polarity vectors of magnitude along the three B–F directions in an ideal trigonal plane.
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| BF3 |
Show that the vector sum is zero using components or symmetry.
Explain why the boron electron deficiency does not automatically imply a permanent dipole.
Would replacing one F with a different substituent preserve the same cancellation argument?
Question 3 - Solution
Cancellation in a trigonal plane
| Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet. |
| BF3 |
Three equivalent polar bonds separated by 120 degrees have zero resultant.
(a)
Choose directions . Their x components sum to , and y components to .
(b)
Electron deficiency describes the local electron inventory. Dipole cancellation concerns the symmetry of the whole charge distribution. Three identical coplanar substituents can cancel their polar contributions even around electron-deficient B.
(c)
No. A different substituent breaks the threefold equivalence, so the equal-vector proof no longer applies. A nonzero dipole is generally allowed; its magnitude requires additional information.