Dipole Moments and Molecular Polarity — Question 3

Section 1-11 · Organic Chemistry pages 215–216

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Cancellation in a trigonal plane

Assign equal outward bond-polarity vectors of magnitude bb along the three B–F directions in an ideal trigonal plane.

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
BF3
  1. Show that the vector sum is zero using components or symmetry.

  2. Explain why the boron electron deficiency does not automatically imply a permanent dipole.

  3. Would replacing one F with a different substituent preserve the same cancellation argument?

Question 3 - Solution

Cancellation in a trigonal plane

Molecular structure shown in the SVG worksheet.
BF3

Three equivalent polar bonds separated by 120 degrees have zero resultant.

(a)

Choose directions 0∘,120∘,240∘0^\circ,120^\circ,240^\circ. Their x components sum to b(1−1/2−1/2)=0b(1-1/2-1/2)=0, and y components to b(0+3/2−3/2)=0b(0+\sqrt3/2-\sqrt3/2)=0.

(b)

Electron deficiency describes the local electron inventory. Dipole cancellation concerns the symmetry of the whole charge distribution. Three identical coplanar substituents can cancel their polar contributions even around electron-deficient B.

(c)

No. A different substituent breaks the threefold equivalence, so the equal-vector proof no longer applies. A nonzero dipole is generally allowed; its magnitude requires additional information.