The History of the Periodic Table — Question 5

Section 7-10 · Chemistry pages 1215–1216

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Check a quantitative forecast against a later measurement

A hypothetical missing-element prediction gives molar mass 70±270\pm2 g/mol and molar volume 12.0±0.512.0\pm0.5 cm3^3/mol, as independent hard bounds. A later measured density is 5.9 g/cm3^3.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the central predicted density and its worst-case bounds.

  2. Does agreement of density alone uniquely identify the element?

Question 5 - Solution

Check a quantitative forecast against a later measurement

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Central density is 70/12.0=5.8370/12.0=5.83 g/cm3^3. Bounds are 68/12.5=5.4468/12.5=5.44 and 72/11.5=6.2672/11.5=6.26 g/cm3^3. The observed 5.9 lies inside.

(b) Analysis

No. Agreement supports consistency with the prediction but is not unique identification. Chemical reactions, characteristic spectra, atomic number and other independent properties would strengthen the assignment.

Check and interpretation

These illustrative values are not presented as Mendeleev's actual historical predictions.