The History of the Periodic Table — Question 4

Section 7-10 · Chemistry pages 1213–1214

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Explain why a successful prediction is a strong test

Mendeleev left gaps and predicted properties of some undiscovered elements. Consider two hypothetical classifications: A lists a missing element's expected oxide formula and density before discovery; B adjusts its groups only after every measurement is known.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Why can a matching later discovery support A more strongly?

  2. What would a substantial mismatch require the investigator to reconsider?

Question 4 - Solution

Explain why a successful prediction is a strong test

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A risks a specific prediction against evidence not used to construct that prediction. A later independent match therefore tests more than the ability to fit an already known list.

(b) Analysis

One should examine the predicted placement, measurement reliability, substance purity and the classification itself. The mismatch must not simply be hidden by unlimited adjustments. Neither one match nor one discrepancy alone settles every aspect of a broad model.

Check and interpretation

Prediction is powerful when it is specific, recorded beforehand and tested independently.