Aromatic Hydrocarbons — Question 3

Section 22-3 · Chemistry pages 3651–3652

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Apply the electron rule only after checking geometry

For this problem, a planar monocyclic system with continuous p-orbital overlap is aromatic with 4n+2 pi electrons and antiaromatic with 4n pi electrons. A system that lacks that continuous planar loop is nonaromatic by this criterion. Classify: A, planar cyclic 6-pi system; B, planar cyclic 4-pi system; C, nonplanar 8-pi ring without continuous parallel overlap.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Classify A, B and C, explaining the geometry and electron-count tests.

  2. Explain why merely finding alternating double bonds in a ring is insufficient to establish aromaticity.

Question 3 - Solution

Apply the electron rule only after checking geometry

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

A is aromatic: its six electrons satisfy 4n+2=64n+2=6 with n = 1 and the required loop is present. B is antiaromatic: four electrons satisfy 4n with n = 1 in a planar conjugated loop. C is nonaromatic under the stated geometry because the continuous planar overlap requirement fails; its eight electrons alone do not establish antiaromaticity.

(b) Analysis

A drawing of alternating bonds gives connectivity and an electron inventory, but not necessarily a planar arrangement with uninterrupted p orbitals. Geometry, orbital availability and electron count must be considered together.

Check and interpretation

The n in the electron rule is a nonnegative integer, not the number of ring carbon atoms.