Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Estimate aromatic stabilization with a common-product comparison
In a hypothetical thermochemical comparison, hydrogenating one isolated alkene unit releases 120 kJ/mol. A localized three-double-bond reference would therefore release 360 kJ/mol on conversion to cyclohexane. Benzene plus three H2 gives the same final product but releases only 208 kJ/mol. Assume the comparison is otherwise consistent.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Estimate how far benzene lies below the localized reference in enthalpy.
Explain why less heat released on hydrogenation indicates a more stable starting material here, and state the limitation of the estimate.
Question 2 - Solution
Estimate aromatic stabilization with a common-product comparison
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The reference has hydrogenation enthalpy -360 kJ/mol and benzene -208 kJ/mol. With the same product and H2 inventory, benzene starts kJ/mol lower in enthalpy.
(b) Analysis
The smaller drop to the same endpoint means a lower starting enthalpy. This is an aromatic-stabilization estimate relative to a constructed localized reference, not a directly separable bond energy or an exact universal measure independent of the reference chosen.
Check and interpretation
The common endpoint is essential: unrelated products would not permit this simple subtraction.