The Group 8A Elements — Question 2

Section 20-8 · Chemistry pages 3429–3430

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Use noble-gas boiling points in a separation argument

Approximate normal boiling points are He 4.2 K, Ne 27 K, Ar 87 K, Kr 120 K and Xe 165 K. Consider each pure substance at 1 atm, initially above 170 K.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain the broad trend and identify which pure gas reaches its condensation boundary first on cooling.

  2. Explain why the same boiling-point list is only a starting point for designing separation of a dilute gas mixture.

Question 2 - Solution

Use noble-gas boiling points in a separation argument

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

All are monatomic with no permanent molecular dipole, but increasing polarizability generally strengthens dispersion attractions. Xenon has the highest listed boiling point and reaches its pure-substance condensation boundary first on cooling.

(b) Analysis

In a mixture, each component has a partial pressure and interacts with other components. Condensation and separation depend on vapor-liquid equilibria, composition and pressure, not solely pure normal boiling points. A very dilute component need not condense at its pure 1-atm boiling temperature.

Check and interpretation

The question's first comparison is explicitly between pure substances, not an unqualified mixture rule.