The Group 8A Elements — Question 1

Section 20-8 · Chemistry pages 3427–3428

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Explain why helium belongs with the noble gases

Helium has configuration 1s21s^2, neon 1s22s22p61s^22s^22p^6, and argon ends in 3s23p63s^23p^6.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why helium belongs to modern Group 18, historically Group 8A, despite having only two electrons.

  2. Explain why a filled shell suggests low reactivity but does not prove that no compound of any noble gas can exist.

Question 1 - Solution

Explain why helium belongs with the noble gases

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The first shell has only one spatial orbital, 1s, so two electrons fill it. Neon and argon fill their outer s and p subshells with eight electrons. Helium shares a closed outer shell and related chemical behavior, not an eight-electron count.

(b) Analysis

Electron removal or sharing is often energetically costly for a closed-shell atom. However, a complete reaction also includes bonding and stabilization of products; sufficiently favorable interactions can support compounds, especially for heavier noble gases. A valence-shell rule is not an absolute prohibition.

Check and interpretation

The octet shorthand must not be imposed on the two-electron first shell.