Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Normalize before looking for multiple proportions
Two different pure compounds contain only A and B. Compound P contains 2.40 g A and 3.20 g B; compound Q contains 3.60 g A and 9.60 g B. Treat values as exact for this model exercise.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate grams of B per gram of A for each compound.
Compare the B masses for a fixed 2.40 g A. Identify the small whole-number ratio.
Why is directly comparing 3.20 g and 9.60 g misleading for this law?
Question 3 - Solution
Normalize before looking for multiple proportions
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
P has g B per g A. Q has g B per g A.
(b) Analysis
For 2.40 g A, P contains 3.20 g B and Q contains 6.40 g B. The B ratio P:Q is , consistent with multiple proportions.
(c) Conclusion
The original B masses accompany different A masses. The law compares one element while holding the mass of the other fixed. The raw ratio 1:3 confounds sample size with composition.
Check and interpretation
Doubling B per unit A is a composition difference, not simply a larger sample.