Fundamental Chemical Laws — Question 2

Section 2-2 · Chemistry pages 209–210

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Test a constant composition across unequal samples

Two pure samples are proposed to be the same binary compound. Sample I contains 3.60 g A and 4.80 g B. Sample II contains 9.00 g A and 12.00 g B. Treat the numerical data as exact for the comparison.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Compare the B:A mass ratios.

  2. Predict the B mass accompanying 15.0 g A in this compound.

  3. Which chemical law is illustrated, and what does the agreement fail to prove by itself?

Question 2 - Solution

Test a constant composition across unequal samples

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Both ratios are 4.80/3.60=12.00/9.00=4/34.80/3.60=12.00/9.00=4/3. Thus the compositions agree despite different sample masses.

(b) Analysis

mB=(4/3)(15.0)=20.0gm_B=(4/3)(15.0)=\boxed{20.0\ \mathrm g}. The total compound mass would be 35.0 g.

(c) Conclusion

This illustrates definite proportions: a given pure compound has a fixed elemental mass ratio. Matching this ratio supports but does not uniquely establish chemical identity or purity; a deliberately proportioned mixture can imitate it.

Check and interpretation

Sample II is 2.5 times sample I in both components.