Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Scale and reverse an extensive thermodynamic change
A specified transformation of 2.00 mol of material between fixed initial and final states has kJ. An otherwise identical transformation uses 0.500 mol.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the Gibbs energy change for the smaller sample and for its reverse.
Explain why the result concerns scaled copies of states, rather than assuming every reacting mixture has constant driving force.
Question 5 - Solution
Scale and reverse an extensive thermodynamic change
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The scale factor is 0.500/2.00 = 0.250, so the forward change is -3.50 kJ and the reverse is +3.50 kJ.
(b) Analysis
Extensivity applies when every amount and the endpoint compositions scale together. Within a finite reacting batch, composition changes as reaction proceeds, so the local molar reaction Gibbs energy generally changes.
Check and interpretation
Reversal changes sign; proportional scaling changes magnitude.