Free Energy — Question 4

Section 16-4 · Chemistry pages 2753–2754

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Check a proposed thermodynamic cycle

For three states at the same T and P, ΔGA→B=+8.0\Delta G_{A\to B}=+8.0 kJ and ΔGB→C=−15.0\Delta G_{B\to C}=-15.0 kJ. A report claims ΔGC→A=+9.0\Delta G_{C\to A}=+9.0 kJ.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Determine the correct C-to-A value and the cycle sum using the claimed value.

  2. Explain why changing the physical pathway cannot repair inconsistent state-function data.

Question 4 - Solution

Check a proposed thermodynamic cycle

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

ΔGA→C=8−15=−7\Delta G_{A\to C}=8-15=-7 kJ, so ΔGC→A=+7\Delta G_{C\to A}=+7 kJ. The reported cycle sums to 8−15+9=+28-15+9=+2 kJ rather than zero.

(b) Analysis

G is a state function, so differences between fixed states are path independent. At least one datum or stated endpoint/condition is inconsistent; an alternative mechanism cannot change the required closure.

Check and interpretation

A complete return to the same state must have zero change in G.