Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Replication cannot erase a common bias
Three laboratories obtain 9.80, 9.81 and 9.79 units for a reference assigned 10.00 units. All three calibrated using bottles from the same mislabeled standard batch.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Explain why close agreement is not sufficient evidence of accuracy.
Propose a genuinely independent check.
Would taking 100 more measurements with the same standard resolve the central problem?
Question 5 - Solution
Replication cannot erase a common bias
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Identify shared dependence
The results are closely grouped, but all laboratories share a calibration source. A common bias can shift all results in the same direction while preserving excellent agreement.
(b) Break the shared link
Analyze an independently certified reference or calibrate with a separately prepared and verified standard. A method using a different calibration chain is especially useful.
(c) Distinguish precision from bias
More measurements can characterize random scatter and improve the mean precision. They do not remove a systematic error in the common calibration; the average may simply become a more precise biased result.
Check and interpretation
Independent replication must examine shared assumptions and reference materials, not only laboratory location.