The Stern-Gerlach Experiment — Question 9

Section 40-4 · Physics pages 6648–6649

Question 9 Gravity shifts the midpoint but leaves magnetic splitting unchanged Two neutral spin components have accelerations az = ±am −g throughout a magnet transit t, followed by drift time td during which only gravity acts. Initially z and vertical velocity vanish. G magnet and detector g Schematic; labels, not drawing lengths, specify the data. (a) Derive both detector positions. (b) Find their midpoint and separation and identify how to extract g and am.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 9 - Solution Gravity shifts the midpoint but leaves magnetic splitting unchanged G magnet and detector g (a) Method and calculation z± = 1 2(±am −g)t2 + (±am −g)ttd −1 2gt2 d. z± = ±amt(td + t/2) −1 2g(t + td)2 . (b) Interpretation and further calculation ¯z = (z+ + z−)/2 = −g(t + td)2/2 . ∆z = 2amt(td + t/2) ; g = −2¯z/(t + td)2. Physical check Gravity is common to both branches and cancels in their difference. The midpoint is measured relative to the undeflected straight trajectory.

Question 9

Gravity shifts the midpoint but leaves magnetic splitting unchanged

Two neutral spin components have accelerations az=±am−ga_z=\pm a_m-g throughout a magnet transit t, followed by drift time tdt_d during which only gravity acts. Initially z and vertical velocity vanish.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive both detector positions.

  2. Find their midpoint and separation and identify how to extract g and ama_m.

Question 9 - Solution

Gravity shifts the midpoint but leaves magnetic splitting unchanged

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Method and calculation

z±=12(±am−g)t2+(±am−g)ttd−12gtd2.z_\pm=\tfrac12(\pm a_m-g)t^2+(\pm a_m-g)tt_d-\tfrac12gt_d^2.z±=±amt(td+t/2)−12g(t+td)2.\boxed{z_\pm=\pm a_mt(t_d+t/2)-\tfrac12g(t+t_d)^2}.

(b) Interpretation and further calculation

z‾=(z++z−)/2=−g(t+td)2/2.\boxed{\bar z=(z_++z_-)/2=-g(t+t_d)^2/2}.Δz=2amt(td+t/2);g=−2z‾/(t+td)2.\boxed{\Delta z=2a_mt(t_d+t/2)};\quad g=-2\bar z/(t+t_d)^2.

Physical check

Gravity is common to both branches and cancels in their difference. The midpoint is measured relative to the undeflected straight trajectory.