Crossed Fields: The Hall Effect — Question 5

Section 28-4 · Physics pages 4540–4541

Question 5 Field reversal removes an even voltage offset from a Hall reading At fixed positive current, a strip gives measured transverse voltages +.820 mV at +B and -.580 mV at -B. Model the measurement as Vmeas(B) = V0 + VH(B), with an unchanged offset V0 and odd Hall response. I U L y x Bˆz w thickness t along z repeat with −B Hall contacts: VH = VU −VL; current points along +x and the shown field along +z. (a) Extract the true Hall voltage at +B and the offset. (b) If the +B reading alone were used to infer density, find the inferred-to-true density ratio in a one-carrier model.
Show solutionHide solution
Question 5 - Solution Field reversal removes an even voltage offset from a Hall reading I U L y x Bˆz w thickness t along z repeat with −B (a) Method and calculation VH(+B) = Vmeas(+B) −Vmeas(−B) 2 = .700 mV. V0 = Vmeas(+B) + Vmeas(−B) 2 = .120 mV. (b) Interpretation and further calculation n ∝1/|VH|. nnaive ntrue = .700 .820 = 35 41 ≃.8537. Physical check Field reversal removes the assumed even offset; it does not automatically remove a contribution that is odd in B.

Question 5

Field reversal removes an even voltage offset from a Hall reading

At fixed positive current, a strip gives measured transverse voltages +.820 mV at +B and -.580 mV at -B. Model the measurement as Vmeas(B)=V0+VH(B)V_{\mathrm{meas}}(B)=V_0+V_H(B), with an unchanged offset V0 and odd Hall response.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Extract the true Hall voltage at +B and the offset.

  2. If the +B reading alone were used to infer density, find the inferred-to-true density ratio in a one-carrier model.

Question 5 - Solution

Field reversal removes an even voltage offset from a Hall reading

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Method and calculation

VH(+B)=Vmeas(+B)−Vmeas(−B)2=.700mV.V_H(+B)=\frac{V_{\mathrm{meas}}(+B)-V_{\mathrm{meas}}(-B)}2=.700\,\mathrm{mV}.V0=Vmeas(+B)+Vmeas(−B)2=.120mV.V_0=\frac{V_{\mathrm{meas}}(+B)+V_{\mathrm{meas}}(-B)}2=.120\,\mathrm{mV}.

(b) Interpretation and further calculation

n∝1/|VH|.n\propto1/|V_H|.nnaiventrue=.700.820=3541≃.8537.\frac{n_{\mathrm{naive}}}{n_{\mathrm{true}}}=\frac{.700}{.820}=\frac{35}{41}\simeq.8537.

Physical check

Field reversal removes the assumed even offset; it does not automatically remove a contribution that is odd in B.