Show solutionHide solution
Question 3
Identify whether proton loss comes before or after departure
A supplied stepwise model first removes a beta proton, leaving a stabilized carbon anion; the anion then forms C=C as the leaving group departs. This defines the E1cB pattern.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
How does the intermediate charge differ from E1?
How does the order of events differ from E1?
Is this the same as a concerted E2 step?
Question 3 - Solution
Identify whether proton loss comes before or after departure
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
The intermediate is a carbanion rather than a carbocation. Stabilization of that anion is part of the stated model.
(b)
E1 begins with leaving-group ionization, whereas this E1cB model begins with deprotonation.
(c)
No. A finite-lived intermediate separates two steps. Three net bond changes do not by themselves prove that those changes were simultaneous.