Alkene Stability — Question 10

Section 8-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1689–1690

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Recognize the limits of a substitution-count shortcut

Both ring alkenes have two carbon substituents on C=C by simple counting. Their ring sizes differ substantially.

Cyclopropene
Cyclohexene
  1. Why does equal substitution count not imply equal strain?

  2. Which ring forces the alkene geometry farther from its preferred angles?

  3. Can simple counting alone supply a quantitative energy difference?

Question 10 - Solution

Recognize the limits of a substitution-count shortcut

Cyclopropene
Cyclohexene

(a)

The count ignores geometric constraints imposed by ring closure. Rings of different size can impose different angle and torsional strain.

(b)

The three-membered ring imposes much more severe angular constraints at the alkene carbons than the six-membered ring.

(c)

No. A numerical comparison requires appropriately referenced thermochemical data or calculations. Substitution count is only one structural factor.