Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Mechanism(s) — Question 10

Section 8-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 1849–1850

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Identify the limit of a bimolecular rate law

Both observed product branches are modeled as elementary bimolecular pathways with the same two reactants.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Can the rate law alone distinguish SN2 from E2?

  2. Assign the mechanisms using the product types.

  3. Write the total rate in terms of the two branch constants.

Question 10 - Solution

Identify the limit of a bimolecular rate law

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. Both SN2 and E2 can be first order in substrate and reagent.

(b)

The ether branch is substitution by SN2; the alkene branch is E2 under the stated elementary-pathway model.

(c)

rtotal=(kSN2+kE2)[substrate][Nu/B]r_{\mathrm{total}}=(k_{\mathrm{SN2}}+k_{\mathrm{E2}})[\mathrm{substrate}][\mathrm{Nu/B}]. At fixed conditions, the product fractions depend on the relative branch constants, not merely their shared rate orders.