Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Mechanism(s) — Question 6

Section 8-13 · Organic Chemistry pages 1841–1842

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Use an observed intermediate to distinguish alternatives

A supplied model for a secondary bromide in an ionizing solvent contains a carbocation intermediate. The isolated organic product is an alkene, and no carbanion intermediate occurs.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which elimination mechanism matches the model?

  2. Which event forms the intermediate?

  3. Why does two-hump shape alone not identify the intermediate charge?

Question 6 - Solution

Use an observed intermediate to distinguish alternatives

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

E1 matches the stated carbocation followed by alkene formation.

(b)

C–Br ionization gives the carbocation; subsequent beta deprotonation gives the alkene.

(c)

A two-step profile only establishes an intermediate between barriers. Its structure or independent evidence is needed to distinguish a carbocation from other possible intermediates.