Substitution vs. Elimination: Identifying the Reagent — Question 7

Section 8-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 1823–1824

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Test the claim that every neutral reagent is a weak base

B is a hypothetical sterically hindered neutral base. In the same solvent, pKaK_a(BH positive) = 24 and pKaK_a(HA) = 16. B has an available lone pair.

B + HA <=> BH+ + A-\text{B + HA <=> BH+ + A-}

  1. Calculate the proton-transfer equilibrium constant.

  2. Which side is favored?

  3. Can these data alone predict a fast SN2 reaction by B?

Question 7 - Solution

Test the claim that every neutral reagent is a weak base

B + HA <=> BH+ + A-\text{B + HA <=> BH+ + A-}

(a)

K=1024−16=108K=10^{24-16}=10^8.

(b)

Products are strongly favored in this supplied model. Neutral charge does not imply weak basicity.

(c)

No. The equilibrium data establish proton affinity on this solvent scale, not a carbon-attack rate. Steric crowding can impede SN2 even when proton transfer is favorable.