Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Repair a final E1 step that removes H from the cation carbon
A student tries to form but-2-ene by removing the H directly on the positively charged C2. Follow instead the correct beta-deprotonation branch at C3.
| Butan-2-yl cation after ionization |
Why is the proposed H the wrong one for C2=C3 formation?
Draw the correct pair of final-step arrows.
State the preceding ionization step and the product geometries that are possible.
Question 10 - Solution
Repair a final E1 step that removes H from the cation carbon
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
| Internal connectivity; E/Z not specified |
(a)
To make C2=C3 by this E1 step, the electron pair must come from a C3–H bond adjacent to C2. Removing the C2 H does not supply the required beta bond pair.
(b)
Water attacks a C3 H; the C3–H pair forms the C2=C3 pi bond.
(c)
C2–Br ionization of 2-bromobutane supplied the cation. E and Z but-2-ene can arise from appropriate cation conformations; this connectivity schematic alone does not set their ratio.