The SN1 Mechanism — Question 7

Section 7-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1503–1504

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Evaluate a proposed SN1 shortcut at methyl carbon

A student argues that iodide is a good leaving group, so methyl iodide must readily undergo SN1 in water.

Methyl iodide
  1. Which hypothetical cation would be required?

  2. Why is leaving-group quality alone insufficient?

  3. Which substitution pathway is normally available with an appropriate nucleophile?

Question 7 - Solution

Evaluate a proposed SN1 shortcut at methyl carbon

Methyl iodide

(a)

The ordinary stepwise proposal would require a methyl cation.

(b)

Even a good leaving group does not make formation of this very unstable cation favorable under ordinary substitution conditions. Substrate structure is decisive.

(c)

Methyl iodide readily permits backside SN2 attack by a suitable nucleophile. An SN1 label cannot be inferred from iodide alone.