Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Identify the experiment that tests the missing hypothesis
Candidate A is direct SN2 substitution; candidate B is rate-limiting ionization followed by capture. Only product connectivity has been measured.
| Same product from two candidate routes |
Design a kinetic comparison.
Design a stereochemical comparison.
Explain why agreement between independent evidence is useful.
Question 10 - Solution
Identify the experiment that tests the missing hypothesis
| Same product from two candidate routes |
(a)
Measure initial rates at several nucleophile concentrations while holding substrate, solvent, temperature and relevant ionic strength fixed.
(b)
Use a configurationally characterized substrate and determine product configuration or enantiomeric composition, accounting for changed CIP priorities.
(c)
Rate dependence and stereochemical outcome test different consequences of a pathway. Consistent evidence is stronger than guessing a mechanism from the product alone.