Reading Energy Diagrams — Question 5

Section 6-6 · Organic Chemistry pages 1279–1280

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Distinguish initial product selection from eventual equilibration

R can form P or Q by the two supplied pathways. Assume comparable prefactors, negligible reverse reaction during a short initial experiment, and no other pathways.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which product is expected to form faster initially?

  2. If P and Q later equilibrate under the same standard-state convention, which is thermodynamically favored?

  3. Why must the observation conditions be stated?

Question 5 - Solution

Distinguish initial product selection from eventual equilibration

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

P has the lower barrier from R, 40 versus 55 kJ per mole, so P forms faster initially under the stated kinetic assumptions.

(b)

Q lies 15 kJ per mole below P and is thermodynamically favored in the stated equal-standard-state comparison.

(c)

Kinetic trapping can preserve an initial product distribution. The equilibrium preference is observed only if the products can interconvert sufficiently on the experimental timescale.