Kinetics — Question 9

Section 6-5 · Organic Chemistry pages 1267–1268

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Judge what an observed rate law can establish about a mechanism

Two independently proposed mechanisms yield the same rate law over the experiments performed.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Does matching the rate law uniquely prove one mechanism?

  2. Name an additional kind of evidence that could distinguish the proposals.

  3. Why can overall equation coefficients not automatically supply an elementary-step rate law?

Question 9 - Solution

Judge what an observed rate law can establish about a mechanism

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

No. A mechanism must be consistent with the data, but different pathways can share a rate law.

(b)

Intermediate detection, isotope labeling, stereochemical outcomes or additional concentration/temperature regimes can distinguish predictions.

(c)

The overall equation can summarize several elementary events. Molecularity-based rate laws apply to an assumed elementary step, not automatically to a net equation.