Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Keep reaction conditions attached to the direction they support
Separate experiments demonstrate A-to-B conversion under one set of conditions and B-to-A conversion under another. No equilibrium compositions were measured.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Do these experiments establish a measured equilibrium constant at 300 K?
How should the observed transformations be reported?
What evidence would support an equilibrium composition at one selected temperature?
Question 10 - Solution
Keep reaction conditions attached to the direction they support
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
No. Observing reverse chemistry under different conditions supplies neither the equilibrium composition nor K at 300 K.
(b)
Retain the conditions on each directional transformation. Do not combine different-temperature observations into an unlabeled equilibrium claim at one temperature.
(c)
Test approach to the same activity ratio from both sides under the same defined conditions, with adequate equilibration and checks against decomposition or open-system removal.