Reversible and Irreversible Reaction Arrows — Question 2

Section 6-12 · Organic Chemistry pages 1393–1394

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Use acid-base data to justify an effectively one-way approximation

In the same solvent and at the same temperature, pKa(HA) = 8 and pKa(HB) = 16. Use K approximately 10 to the power [pKa(HB)-pKa(HA)].

HA + B^- <=> A^- + HB\text{HA + B^- <=> A^- + HB}

  1. Estimate K for the written proton transfer.

  2. When might a single forward arrow be a useful practical shorthand?

  3. Does that shorthand mean the microscopic reverse reaction is mathematically impossible?

Question 2 - Solution

Use acid-base data to justify an effectively one-way approximation

HA + B^- <=> A^- + HB\text{HA + B^- <=> A^- + HB}

(a)

K is approximately 10 to power 8, strongly favoring the products in the standard equilibrium comparison.

(b)

It may summarize an effectively complete proton transfer at concentrations and accuracy where the remaining reactants are negligible. State the relevant conditions.

(c)

No. A finite K still permits a reverse process. A practical one-way approximation is not a claim of an infinite equilibrium constant.