Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Test the effect of an isotope label on a meso symmetry
Replace every H in the left terminal CH3 group by D, creating CD3 there; leave the right terminal CH3 unchanged. Retain both stereocenter geometries.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Does the indicated reflection still map identical groups onto one another?
Do the two formerly equivalent ends remain interchangeable?
Is the isotope-labeled (2S,3R) form still meso?
Question 8 - Solution
Test the effect of an isotope label on a meso symmetry
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
No. Reflection would exchange CD3 with CH3, which are isotopically distinct.
(b)
No. The isotopic label breaks the end-for-end equivalence.
(c)
No. This labeled two-center molecule lacks the former internal equivalence and is chiral. Its mirror has inverted configurations and cannot be identified by exchanging unlike ends.