Optical Activity — Question 9

Section 5-4 · Organic Chemistry pages 1067–1068

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Subtract the blank before deciding whether a sign is resolved

Use worst-case interval subtraction rather than statistical standard-error propagation.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the nominal corrected rotation.

  2. Calculate its full allowed interval.

  3. Can these bounds establish the sign of the true corrected rotation?

Question 9 - Solution

Subtract the blank before deciding whether a sign is resolved

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a)

The nominal corrected rotation is +0.15−(+0.10)=+0.05∘+0.15-(+0.10)=+0.05^\circ.

(b)

The extremes are 0.11−0.14=−0.03∘0.11-0.14=-0.03^\circ and 0.19−0.06=+0.13∘0.19-0.06=+0.13^\circ.

(c)

No. The interval includes both signs and zero. The positive nominal result does not establish a positive true rotation within these stated bounds.