Overview of Isomerism — Question 7

Section 5-1 · Organic Chemistry pages 1003–1004

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Do not count resonance contributors as separate isomers

These are two conventional contributors for the same acetate ion; oxygen lone pairs are omitted for clarity.

Contributor A
Contributor B
  1. Which atom connections remain unchanged?

  2. What changes between the contributors?

  3. Should they count as two constitutional or configurational isomers?

Question 7 - Solution

Do not count resonance contributors as separate isomers

Contributor A
Contributor B

(a)

The CH3–C and both C–O connections are unchanged, as are all atom positions in the resonance description.

(b)

The formal placement of a pi bond and a negative charge changes.

(c)

Neither. Resonance contributors describe electron distribution in one species; they are not distinct molecules interconverting by atom motion.