Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Explain threefold equivalence despite one methyl substituent
Consider rotation about the displayed terminal bond in propane, without isotopic labeling.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Are its three staggered minima equivalent by symmetry?
Why does the single rear methyl not create distinct anti and gauche families here?
What would make labeled hydrogen positions distinguishable in a tracking experiment?
Question 6 - Solution
Explain threefold equivalence despite one methyl substituent
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a)
Yes. The front methyl carbon bears three equivalent H atoms.
(b)
Every staggered arrangement places the rear CH3 opposite one of those equivalent front H atoms. There is no second methyl substituent on the front carbon.
(c)
Isotopic labeling could distinguish particular hydrogens for tracking. It would require a separately specified labeled molecule and symmetry analysis.